Is Maison Asrar Muharib a dupe of Xerjoff Naxos?

Close match Widely recommended as a substitute, and most people who compared them agree.

Maison Asrar Muharib is a close match to Xerjoff Naxos. Of 24 independent sources that compared them, 22 say it is near-identical or close, 2 say it is similar or inspired by it and 0 disagree. Muharib costs $51.00 for 100 ml at My Royal Musk ($0.51/ml); Naxos costs $186.00 for 100 ml at MicroPerfumes ($1.86/ml), so the alternative costs 73% less per ml. Prices are checked every 20 minutes. These figures last changed on Oct 24, 2026.

Accords
	Xerjoff Naxos	Maison Asrar Muharib
Price	$186 100 ml	$51 100 ml
Per ml	$1.86	$0.51
Verdict		Close match of Naxos
Sweet
Citrus
Tobacco
Warm spicy
Aromatic
Vanilla
Woody
White floral
Notes shared notes are marked
Top notes	Lavender Bergamot Lemon	Lavender Lemon Bergamot
Heart notes	Honey Cinnamon Cashmeran Jasmine sambac	Honey Cinnamon Cashmere wood
Base notes	Tobacco leaf Vanilla Tonka bean	Tobacco Tonka bean
Buy	See prices	See prices

The evidence

24 independent sources: 24 on Reddit

Say near-identical 3
Say close 19
Say similar or inspired by 2

When people said it: 30 in the last two years

Confidence: 89%. It combines how many independent sources agree, how strongly they word it, how recent they are and how many disagree. How confidence works

In their words 15

So today I received Muharib by Maison Asrar which is a clone of Xerjoff Naxos.

A Reddit post, Dec 2025, 40 points
Muharib is clearly meant to be a dupe of Naxos, and I would say it gets about 85 percent of the way there, but only for the first hour.

A Reddit post, Jan 2026, 30 points
Overall I do not believe Muharib is a good dupe of Naxos.

A Reddit post, Mar 2026, 19 points
Maison asrar muharib (Naxos): This is (almost) how you do a naxos clone.For the price i am not one to complain,and since the performance is good,this is prob going on my shelf.

A Reddit post, Apr 2026, 10 points
Glws, just wanted to clarify that Muharib is a Naxos clone (faris al arab is blonde amber)

A Reddit comment, Mar 2026, 3 points
Maison Asrar Muharib is the closest “clone” of Xerjoff Naxos .

A Reddit comment, Apr 2026, 2 points
People are saying it’s 1:1 to xerjoff Naxos, but stronger

A Reddit comment, Sep 2025, 1 point
Muharib is smooth and extremely similar to Naxos, I’d say 90% (no cap)

A Reddit comment, Dec 2025, 1 point
I wanted to get Muharib for a Naxos clone, but just saw Italia for $33 shipped on beautyhouse.

A Reddit comment, Jan 2026, 1 point
muharib is actually a naxos clone as far as I'm aware

A Reddit comment, Feb 2026, 1 point
Muharib by maison asrar or rayhaan atalia both dupes of xerjoff Naxos and they do it exceptionally well 👍 or aristo by Arabiyat prestige which is citrusy ginger with a nice vanilla drydown, it is a clone of ingenious ginger by goldfield & banks 👍

A Reddit comment, Mar 2026, 1 point
Maison asrar muharib is the Naxos clone you need if you are looking.

A Reddit comment, Jul 2026, 1 point

All 15 quotes

muharib is a naxos clone

A Reddit comment, Sep 2026, 1 point
Muharib is the only clone of Naxos that I would recommend.

A Reddit comment, Sep 2026, 1 point
And I can tell you that Fierte Luna is the absolute best fragrance with this DNA (yes, it’s honestly better than the original in every single way), while Muharib takes second place for me as an amazing twist on the original.

A Reddit comment, Jul 2026, -6 points

How the verdict is worked out is on the how it works page.

Is Maison Asrar Muharib a dupe of Xerjoff Naxos?

The evidence

In their words 15

Among the alternatives to Naxos