Is Alexandria Fragrances Dark Knight a dupe of Kilian Black Phantom?
Inspired by The maker names it as the inspiration, or most people describe it as a take on it.
Alexandria Fragrances Dark Knight is inspired by Kilian Black Phantom. Of 13 independent sources that compared them, 10 say it is near-identical or close, 1 say it is similar or inspired by it and 2 disagree. Dark Knight costs $112.99 for 100 ml at Alexandria Fragrances ($1.13/ml); Black Phantom costs $305.00 for 50 ml at Luckyscent ($6.10/ml), so the alternative costs 81% less per ml. Prices are checked every 20 minutes. These figures last changed on .
Kilian
Black Phantom
|
Alexandria Fragrances
Dark Knight
| |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $305 50 ml | $47.99 30 ml |
| Per ml | $6.10 | $1.60 |
| Verdict | Inspired by of Black Phantom | |
| Accords | ||
| Gourmand | ||
| Sweet | ||
| Woody | ||
| Boozy | ||
| Powdery | ||
| Notes shared notes are marked | ||
| Top notes |
| |
| Heart notes |
| |
| Base notes |
| |
| Notes |
| |
| Buy | See prices | See prices |
The evidence
- Say near-identical 1
- Say close 9
- Say similar or inspired by 1
- Disagree 2
Confidence: 49%. It combines how many independent sources agree, how strongly they word it, how recent they are and how many disagree. How confidence works
The maker
Introducing our newest fragrance, Dark Knight, inspired by Kilian Black Phantom. 🟠This seductive
In their words 7
A friend told me Dark Knight a clone of Black Phantom is a must try.
A Reddit post, May 2023, 8 points
Alexandria has Dark Knight, and while it is expensive, I’ve compared the two side by side and found Dark Knight to be stronger, while being spot on.
A Reddit comment, Nov 2023, 6 points
I'm a big fan of those dark, gothic scents and while I enjoy Kilian fragrances, my wallet does not 😂 Dark Knight by Alexandria Fragrances is a great clone of Kilian's Black Phantom but I've yet to find a clone of Dark Lord.
A Reddit post, Oct 2023, 3 points
Either of the dupes I linked you to are going to be a pickup of mine soon.
A Reddit comment, Jun 2022, 2 points
I was looking for a Black Phantom clone and i read a lot of good reviews about Dark Knight and i decided to give it a try.
A Reddit post, Sep 2022, 2 points
Alexandria Dark Knight is 95% close.
A Reddit comment, Nov 2020, 1 point
I got the Black Phantom clone called Dark Knight, and it smells way off.
A Reddit comment, Oct 2023, 2 points, disagrees
How the verdict is worked out is on the how it works page.