Scentome

Is Armaf Club De Nuit Sillage a dupe of Creed Silver Mountain Water?

Close dupe Widely recommended as a substitute by several independent people.

Most people who compared them prefer Club De Nuit Sillage: 4 of 5.

Armaf Club De Nuit Sillage is a close dupe of Creed Silver Mountain Water: of 87 independent voices that compared them, 77 say it is near-identical or close, 8 say it is similar or inspired by it and 2 disagree. 3 community dupe lists include it. Club De Nuit Sillage costs $31.99 for 105 ml at Triple Traders ($0.30/ml); Silver Mountain Water costs $399.95 for 100 ml at Perfumania ($4.00/ml), so the alternative costs 92% less per ml. Scentome re-checks prices every 20 minutes; these facts last changed on .

Creed Silver Mountain Water Creed Silver Mountain Water Armaf Club De Nuit Sillage Armaf Club De Nuit Sillage
Price$399.95 100 ml$31.99 105 ml
Per ml$4.00$0.30
VerdictClose dupe of Silver Mountain Water
Accords
Green
Citrus
Floral
Powdery
Musky
White floral
Fruity
Woody
Notes shared notes are marked
Top notes
  • Bergamot
  • Mandarin orange
  • Bergamot
  • Lemon
  • Lime
  • Ginger
  • Blackcurrant
  • Violet
Heart notes
  • Green tea
  • Black currant
  • Jasmine
  • Iris
  • Rose
Base notes
  • Musk
  • Petitgrain
  • Sandalwood
  • Galbanum
    See pricesSee prices

    The evidence

    87 independent voices: 83 on Reddit, 3 dupe lists, 1 shops
    • Say near-identical 5
    • Say close 72
    • Say similar or inspired by 8
    • Disagree 2
    When people said it: 45 in the last two years
    2021: 3 agreeing320212022: 3 agreeing320222023: 8 agreeing820232024: 27 agreeing2024: 2 disagreeing2720242025: 27 agreeing2720252026: 18 agreeing182026

    Confidence in the verdict: 97%, from how many independent voices agree, how strongly, how recently and how much they disagree.

    In their words 45

    All 45 quotes
    • Club de Nuit Sillage - clone of Creed Silver Mountain Water

      A Reddit comment, Apr 2024, 3 points

    • He meant is it better than club de Nuit sillage which is the most popular Silver Mountain Water dupe.

      A Reddit comment, May 2024, 3 points

    • Armaf CDN Sillage is a great clone of Creed SMW.

      A Reddit comment, Aug 2024, 3 points

    • Armaf CDN Sillage for a SMW clone

      A Reddit comment, Feb 2025, 3 points

    • Try Club De Nuit Sillage as a dupe for Creed Silver Mountain Water.

      A Reddit comment, Jan 2025, 2 points

    • I'm also looking for something very similar to Creed Silver Mountain Water and apparently Club de Nuit Sillage Armaf is meant to be similar enough.

      A Reddit post, May 2022, 2 points

    • I think it's a decent dupe of SMW, or at least a decent frag in its own right, and it's a monster.

      A Reddit comment, Aug 2023, 2 points

    • Cdn sillage smell like an older batch of smw.

      A Reddit comment, Apr 2021, 2 points

    • CDN Sillage (clone of SMW) has a pretty prominent tea note iirc

      A Reddit comment, Nov 2023, 2 points

    • CDN Sillage for Silver Mountain Water & CDN Milestone for Millesime Imperialle

      A Reddit comment, May 2024, 2 points

    • If you want SMW Club De Nuit Sillage is a much better clone.

      A Reddit comment, Feb 2024, 2 points

    • I'd also recommend Club de Nuit Sillage which is a clone of Silver Mountain Water.

      A Reddit comment, Jun 2024, 2 points

    • It’s still a little too sweet and synthetically musky if you smell directly where you sprayed, but the scent trail you leave behind is practically identical between the two.

      A Reddit comment, Jul 2025, 2 points

    • BTW if you want a clone of Creed Silver Mountain Water checkout Club De Nuit Sillage.

      A Reddit comment, Jun 2022, 1 point

    • Although the best clone for that is Club De Nuit Sillage.

      A Reddit comment, Feb 2023, 1 point

    • I don't have this fragrance but i have hear a lot of good stuff about Club de nuit sillage which is a clone of creed silver mountain water.

      A Reddit comment, May 2022, 1 point

    • Because I have club de nuit sillage and it is inspired by SMW like the blanche for men, plus as I told you this smell extremely feminine and it definitely has a strong rose smell, so it seems to be some mixup that had happen.

      A Reddit comment, Jan 2025, 1 point

    • Club de Nuit Sillage is close to Silver Mountain Water.

      A Reddit comment, Jun 2023, 1 point

    • CDN Sillage - Creed SMW on steroids, if you like that profile this is another power house

      A Reddit comment, Mar 2025, 1 point

    • It is basically the same as SMW but with better longevity and projection.

      A Reddit post, Apr 2025, 1 point

    • I must say your collection is nice might I add a suggestion try club de nuit sillage it’s a clone of creed silver mountain water it’s become my recent favorite spring and summer cologne

      A Reddit comment, Jun 2024, 1 point

    • Bro, Club de Nuit Sillage is a great alternative to Creeds Silver Mountain Water, according to a lot of fragrance experts it smells how Silver Mountain Water used to smell with a lot better performance.

      A Reddit comment, Oct 2024, 1 point

    • Supremacy in Heaven is my top favorite, which is why I recently purchased CDN Sillage after hearing it’s a stronger clone of Creed SMW.

      A Reddit comment, Oct 2024, 1 point

    • CDN Sillage and SIH are commonly regarded as the best clones for SMW so if you don't like them you might be out of luck unfortunately

      A Reddit comment, Feb 2025, 1 point

    • Club de Nuit Sillage as a Silver Mountain Water alternative is 👌🏽

      A Reddit comment, Mar 2025, 1 point

    • Creed "Silver Mountain Water" it's what CDN Sillage is supposed to be a dupe of

      A Reddit comment, Jul 2025, 1 point

    • Club de nuit Sillage(smw clone)

      A Reddit comment, Aug 2025, 1 point

    • There are so many twists on this profile that are a bit divergent from the original that I tend to just stick with CDN Sillage for SMW clones even though the quality is a bit synthetic.

      A Reddit comment, Jul 2026, 1 point

    • CDN Sillage is a pretty good SMW dupe.

      A Reddit comment, Sep 2026, 1 point

    • nice try diddy but CDN Sillage resembles older stronger batches of Creed Silver Mountain Water when compared to the newer watered down trash batches of the same as told by former creed employee https://youtu.be/LdWJV\_aEYFc there's absolutely no reason to break your b

      A Reddit comment, Jul 2026, 0 points

    • CdN Sillage is the classic SMW alternative.

      A Reddit comment, Jan 2025, 0 points

    • Club de Nuit Sillage is definitely Armaf's more popular dupe for Creed Silver Mountain Water, but before that, there was this.

      A Reddit post, Jul 2025, 0 points

    Community dupe lists

    Shops

    How the verdict is worked out is on the how it works page.

    Among the alternatives to Silver Mountain Water

    Silver Mountain Water and its 15 alternatives: clones and close dupes on the inner ring, impressions in the middle, similar scents outside. Thicker lines, more agreement., strongest first.
    Armaf Club De Nuit Sillage: Close dupeClub De Nuit Sill…Dossier Musky Green Tea: Inspired byMusky Green TeaAl Rehab Silver: SimilarSilverAfnan Supremacy In Heaven: Close dupeSupremacy In Heav…Dua Fragrances Water of Arabia: Inspired byWater of ArabiaRiiffs Prive Platinum: SimilarPrive PlatinumArmaf Sillage: Close dupeSillageOil Perfumery Silver Mountain Water Impression: Inspired bySilver Mountain W…Arabiyat Prestige Ash'aa Blanc: SimilarAsh'aa BlancRasasi Al Wisam Day: Close dupeAl Wisam DayLattafa Maharjan Silver: Close dupeMaharjan SilverAl Haramain L'Aventure Blanche: Close dupeL'Aventure BlancheArmaf Derby Club House Blanche: Close dupeDerby Club House …Ajmal Silver Shade: Close dupeSilver ShadeAl Haramain L'Aventure Fraiche: Close dupeL'Aventure FraicheSilver Mountain W…
    1. Armaf Club De Nuit SillageClose dupe
    2. Afnan Supremacy In HeavenClose dupe
    3. Armaf SillageClose dupe
    4. Rasasi Al Wisam DayClose dupe
    5. Lattafa Maharjan SilverClose dupe
    6. Al Haramain L'Aventure BlancheClose dupe
    7. Armaf Derby Club House BlancheClose dupe
    8. Ajmal Silver ShadeClose dupe
    9. Al Haramain L'Aventure FraicheClose dupe
    10. Dossier Musky Green TeaInspired by
    11. Dua Fragrances Water of ArabiaInspired by
    12. Oil Perfumery Silver Mountain Water ImpressionInspired by
    13. Al Rehab SilverSimilar
    14. Riiffs Prive PlatinumSimilar
    15. Arabiyat Prestige Ash'aa BlancSimilar