Is Khadlaj Onyx Silver a dupe of Parfums de Marly Castley?
Close match Widely recommended as a substitute, and most people who compared them agree.
Khadlaj Onyx Silver is a close match to Parfums de Marly Castley. Of 8 independent sources that compared them, 7 say it is near-identical or close, 1 say it is similar or inspired by it and 0 disagree. Onyx Silver costs CA$54.99 for 100 ml at My Royal Musk (CA$0.55/ml); Castley costs CA$242.99 for 75 ml at Fragrance Cart (CA$3.24/ml), so the alternative costs 83% less per ml. Prices are checked every 20 minutes. These figures last changed on .
Parfums de Marly
Castley
|
Khadlaj
Onyx Silver
| |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $242.99 75 ml | $54.99 100 ml |
| Per ml | $3.24 | $0.55 |
| Verdict | Close match of Castley | |
| Accords | ||
| Fresh spicy | ||
| Citrus | ||
| Amber | ||
| Resinous | ||
| Earthy | ||
| Woody | ||
| Sweet | ||
| Aromatic | ||
| Notes shared notes are marked | ||
| Top notes |
|
|
| Heart notes |
|
|
| Base notes |
|
|
| Buy | See prices | See prices |
The evidence
- Say near-identical 1
- Say close 6
- Say similar or inspired by 1
Confidence: 71%. It combines how many independent sources agree, how strongly they word it, how recent they are and how many disagree. How confidence works
In their words 2
Castley dupes like Onyx Silver and Mahajan Desperado Frontier.
A Reddit comment, Oct 2026, 5 points
Onyx Silver is supposedly a twist on Castley with some imagination mixed somewhere in it .
A Reddit comment, Apr 2026, 1 point
How the verdict is worked out is on the how it works page.